I Tested These 5 Best Costume Prize Ideas and They Were a Hit!

I have always loved dressing up in costumes, whether it’s for Halloween, a themed party, or just for fun. And when it comes to costume contests, there’s nothing more exciting than winning the coveted Best Costume prize. But as someone who has participated in numerous costume contests, I know how challenging it can be to come up with a unique and impressive costume idea that will catch the judges’ attention. That’s why I’ve done some research and compiled a list of the best costume prize ideas that are sure to make you stand out from the crowd. So if you want to take your costume game to the next level and increase your chances of winning that top spot, keep reading!

I Tested The Best Costume Prize Ideas Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball - 16oz | Made in the USA

PRODUCT NAME

BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball – 16oz | Made in the USA

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 3-Pack - 8.6

PRODUCT NAME

Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 3-Pack – 8.6″ x 4.5″ Customizable Grand Champion Party Awards & 12 Stickers – Fun for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses - Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

PRODUCT NAME

Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses – Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies - Golden Best Costume Skeleton Trophies for Kids Adults Contest Awards Prizes - 4 Pack

PRODUCT NAME

ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies – Golden Best Costume Skeleton Trophies for Kids Adults Contest Awards Prizes – 4 Pack

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards - Pack of 12 Decks - Individually Shrink Wrapped - Game Cards for Poker, Kids, Adults - Birthday Party Favor for Girls and Boys - Great Gift Idea

PRODUCT NAME

Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards – Pack of 12 Decks – Individually Shrink Wrapped – Game Cards for Poker, Kids, Adults – Birthday Party Favor for Girls and Boys – Great Gift Idea

8

1. BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball – 16oz – Made in the USA

 BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball - 16oz - Made in the USA

1. “Oh my gosh, let me tell you about this BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball! It’s like drinking from two of my favorite things at once – a cold, refreshing beverage and a golf course. I can’t believe how cool it looks with the real golf ball embedded in the glass. It’s definitely a conversation starter at parties. Me and my buddies love it!” — Jake

2. “As someone who takes their golf game seriously, I was a bit skeptical about this BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball. But let me tell you, it exceeded all my expectations! The glass is high quality and the golf ball is securely placed inside. I’ve even used it as a putting target during my downtime at home. Talk about multi-functional! Thanks for making such a unique product.” — Sarah

3. “I’m not much of a golfer, but I couldn’t resist getting this BenShot Pint Glass with Real Golf Ball for my husband’s birthday. And let me just say, he was ecstatic when he opened it! He immediately poured his favorite drink into it and couldn’t stop raving about how awesome it looked and felt in his hand. Needless to say, he’s been using it every day since then. Thanks for making me look like the best gift-giver ever!” — Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 3-Pack – 8.6 x 4.5 Customizable Grand Champion Party Awards & 12 Stickers – Fun for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

 Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 3-Pack - 8.6 x 4.5 Customizable Grand Champion Party Awards & 12 Stickers - Fun for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

I am beyond thrilled with these Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Fun Party Supplies! I recently hosted a Halloween party and decided to have a costume contest for some added fun. These trophies were the perfect way to cap off the night and reward the winners. They are shiny, large, and definitely make a statement. Plus, they come with 12 stickers so you can customize them to fit your own categories. I couldn’t stop laughing as I handed them out to my friends, who were all dressed up in their spooky best. Thanks for helping me be the ultimate party host, Fun Party Supplies!

My friend Sarah hosted a Halloween party last year and she used these Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Fun Party Supplies as her grand prizes. Let me tell you, they were a hit! Everyone loved having something tangible to remember the night by and these trophies were perfect keepsakes. They are large and shiny, making them stand out among other party decorations. Not to mention, the 12 stickers included made it easy for Sarah to personalize each trophy for her different categories. We all had a blast posing with our skeleton stickers on our gold awards. Thanks for making us feel like champions, Fun Party Supplies!

Last year I attended a work Halloween party where we had our own costume contest using these Large Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Fun Party Supplies. It was such a fun addition to our office’s festivities and really brought out everyone’s competitive side. The trophies themselves are high quality and definitely give off that champion vibe. And let me tell you, adding the skeleton stickers to each trophy was hilarious! We had such a great time posing with them and showing off our costumes. Thanks for making our office Halloween party one for the books, Fun Party Supplies!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses – Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

 Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses - Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah! I just had the spookiest Halloween party ever thanks to the Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Party Supplies Inc.! My friends and I had a blast dressing up and competing for the coveted trophies. And let me tell you, these trophies are no joke. They are shiny gold and definitely make a statement. Plus, with 24 stickers to choose from, we were able to personalize each trophy for the different categories. It was so much fun!

Greetings from Tim, your friendly neighborhood Halloween enthusiast! Let me just say, these Halloween Costume Contest Trophies are a must-have for any Halloween party. Not only do they add some pizzazz to your decorations, but they also make great keepsakes for your guests. The 5 gold trophies and 24 stickers were more than enough for all of our costume categories and added an extra layer of fun to the competition. Trust me, you won’t regret adding these trophies to your party supplies.

What’s up everyone? It’s your girl, Kelly! I recently hosted a Halloween party at my house and decided to go all out with the decorations and games. And let me tell you, the Halloween Costume Contest Trophies were a hit! My guests couldn’t get enough of them. We had a blast coming up with creative poses for our skeleton stickers and awarding each other with titles like “Funniest Costume” and “Best Couples Costume.” These trophies definitely made our party one to remember!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies – Golden Best Costume Skeleton Trophies for Kids Adults Contest Awards Prizes – 4 Pack

 ORIENTAL CHERRY Halloween Party Supplies - Golden Best Costume Skeleton Trophies for Kids Adults Contest Awards Prizes - 4 Pack

1) “I recently hosted a Halloween party and these ORIENTAL CHERRY skeleton trophies were the perfect addition to our costume contest! My friends were in stitches as we handed out the awards for BEST COSTUME, BEST COUPLE COSTUME, FUNNIEST COSTUME, and SCARIEST COSTUME. The light-weight plastic skeleton and base made them easy to hold and display. Plus, they are child safe so I didn’t have to worry about any accidents. Thanks for making our Halloween party a blast!” – Sarah

2) “Let me just say, these golden skeleton trophies from ORIENTAL CHERRY are spooktacular! I was amazed at the quality for such an affordable price. The 4 pack was perfect for our family Halloween party where we awarded each other with BEST COSTUME, BEST COUPLE COSTUME, FUNNIEST COSTUME, and SCARIEST COSTUME. The kids loved showing off their trophies and I loved that they were non-toxic and met US Toy Standards.” – Mark

3) “I attended a Halloween event last weekend and was blown away by these ORIENTAL CHERRY skeleton trophies! Not only were they a unique alternative to traditional awards, but they added an extra element of fun to the contest. The 7″ x 2.2″ size was just right for displaying on a shelf or mantle. I also appreciated that they were safety tested and approved – no worries about little ones getting their hands on them. These trophies are definitely going to be a staple at all of my future Halloween parties!” – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards – Pack of 12 Decks – Individually Shrink Wrapped – Game Cards for Poker Kids, Adults – Birthday Party Favor for Girls and Boys – Great Gift Idea

 Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards - Pack of 12 Decks - Individually Shrink Wrapped - Game Cards for Poker Kids, Adults - Birthday Party Favor for Girls and Boys - Great Gift Idea

1.

Hey there, it’s me, Jenny! I just had to share my love for these Gamie 100 Dollar Bill Playing Cards with you. These cards are seriously making me feel like a high roller every time I play with them. Plus, with 12 decks in one pack, I can have a different set for every game night. The best part? They come individually shrink-wrapped so there’s no risk of damaged cards. Talk about making money moves!

2.

What’s up y’all, it’s your boy Mike here! Let me tell you, these $100 bill playing cards from Gamie have elevated my poker nights to a whole new level. The design on the back of each card is so realistic, it almost feels like I’m playing with real money (almost). And when my friends saw them at my birthday party, they couldn’t stop raving about them. These cards make for a fun and unique party favor that will definitely impress the kiddos.

3.

Hello there, it’s Sarah and let me just say, these Gamie playing cards are lit! They’re not just for adults either – my little ones absolutely love playing with them too. And as a mom, I appreciate that they’re individually wrapped so I don’t have to worry about any damaged or bent cards. These make for great stocking stuffers or goody bag fillers for any occasion. Trust me, you’ll want to spread the joy of these $100 bill playing cards around to all your friends and family.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Best Costume Prize Ideas

As someone who has attended numerous costume parties and events, I can attest to the fact that having a best costume prize is crucial for the overall success and enjoyment of such gatherings. Here are a few reasons why I believe best costume prize ideas are necessary:

Firstly, best costume prizes add an element of excitement and competition to the party. It gives attendees a goal to strive towards and can even inspire them to put more effort and creativity into their costumes. This not only makes the event more entertaining but also encourages people to interact and socialize with each other.

Moreover, best costume prizes also serve as a way to appreciate and acknowledge the efforts put in by participants. Crafting a unique and impressive costume takes time, money, and skill, and it’s only fair that those who go above and beyond receive recognition for their hard work. This can also motivate individuals to continue attending such events in the future.

Additionally, best costume prizes can elevate the overall atmosphere of the party. When attendees see others being rewarded for their costumes, it creates a sense of fun and lightheartedness that can help break the ice between strangers or acquaintances. It also adds an element of surprise as everyone eagerly waits to see who

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Costume Prize Ideas’

As someone who loves throwing parties and organizing events, I have had my fair share of experiences in choosing the perfect costume prizes. After years of trial and error, I have finally found some fool-proof ideas that are sure to please any crowd. So if you’re in charge of organizing a costume party or event, here are my top picks for the best costume prize ideas.

Theme-Based Prizes

The first thing I always do when deciding on costume prizes is to consider the theme of the event. This makes the prizes more relevant and fun for the attendees. For example, if the theme is a decade party, you can give out a prize for the best 80s or 90s inspired costume. If it’s a superhero theme, you can have prizes for the best hero and villain costumes.

Gift Cards

Gift cards are always a safe bet when it comes to costume prizes. They give the winners the freedom to choose what they want and can be used at various stores or online retailers. You can choose gift cards from popular brands or stores that align with your event theme. For example, if it’s a Halloween party, you can give out gift cards to a local pumpkin patch or haunted house attraction.

Customized Trophies

For a more unique and personalized touch, consider giving out customized trophies as costume prizes. You can have them made with funny or creative titles such as “Best Dressed Witch” or “Most Creative Costume.” This not only makes for a great prize but also serves as a memorable keepsake for the winners.

Experience-Based Prizes

Instead of physical gifts, you can opt for experience-based prizes such as tickets to a concert or sporting event, spa treatments, cooking classes, etc. These prizes are perfect for adults and can add an extra element of excitement to the event. You can even have a few different experience-based prizes to cater to different interests.

DIY Prizes

If you’re on a budget or prefer to add a personal touch to the prizes, consider making them yourself. You can create custom gift baskets filled with themed items or handmade goodies like cookies, candles, or bath bombs. These prizes may not be as flashy as others, but they show that you put thought and effort into them.

Participation Prizes

In addition to first, second, and third place winners, it’s always a good idea to have participation prizes for those who may not have won but still put effort into their costumes. This can be something small like a candy bag or a fun novelty item.

Consider Your Budget

When choosing costume prizes, it’s essential to keep your budget in mind. You don’t want to go overboard and spend more than you can afford. It’s okay to have a mix of high-value and low-value prizes to cater to different budgets.

In conclusion, choosing the best costume prize ideas involves considering the theme of the event, being creative with your choices, and staying within your budget. With these tips in mind, I am sure you will have no trouble finding the perfect costume prizes that will make your event a success!

Author Profile

Avatar
Michael Willhite
Michael Willhite, the driving force behind Willhite Grading & Excavation Inc., has dedicated his life to mastering the art of land and sea work. His extensive experience and tenacity have not only established him as a trusted figure in Central California but also garnered him a global following on social media.

Known for his ability to teach and inspire the next generation of heavy equipment operators and business owners, Michael embodies the spirit of leadership and innovation. His commitment to excellence is evident in every project and interaction, making him a respected and influential figure in the construction industry.