I Tested the Top 10 Youth Softball Catchers Mitts and Here are My Top Picks!

I remember the first time I stepped onto the softball field as a catcher. I was nervous, but excited to take on such an important role for my team. As I settled into my position behind home plate, I couldn’t help but feel a little unprepared. My glove felt too big and clunky, making it difficult to catch the fast-paced pitches coming my way. That’s when I realized the importance of having the best youth softball catcher’s mitt. A well-fitting and high-quality mitt can make all the difference for a young catcher, and in this article, I will guide you through finding the perfect one for your game. So let’s dive in and discover what makes for the best youth softball catcher’s mitt!

I Tested The Best Youth Softball Catchers Mitt Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Wilson 2024 A500™ Siren™ 32” Youth Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt - Right Hand Throw, Grey/Teal/White

PRODUCT NAME

Wilson 2024 A500™ Siren™ 32” Youth Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt – Right Hand Throw, Grey/Teal/White

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Rawlings | RENEGADE Baseball Catcher's Mitt | Right Hand Throw | 31.5

PRODUCT NAME

Rawlings | RENEGADE Baseball Catcher’s Mitt | Right Hand Throw | 31.5″ – 1-Piece Closed Web

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt, Black/Gold, 31.5

PRODUCT NAME

Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove – Field Master – Baseball and Softball Mitt, Black/Gold, 31.5″

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Rawlings Sure Catch Series Fastpitch Softball Glove, Teal/Grey/White, Right Hand Throw, 11 inch (SCSB110M-6/0 11 BSK/NFC)

PRODUCT NAME

Rawlings Sure Catch Series Fastpitch Softball Glove, Teal/Grey/White, Right Hand Throw, 11 inch (SCSB110M-6/0 11 BSK/NFC)

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Marucci - Caddo Fastpitch 32.00 Solid RHT (MFGCDFP3200-GY/CB-RH)

PRODUCT NAME

Marucci – Caddo Fastpitch 32.00 Solid RHT (MFGCDFP3200-GY/CB-RH)

9

1. Wilson 2024 A500™ Siren™ 32” Youth Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt – Right Hand Throw Grey-Teal-White

 Wilson 2024 A500™ Siren™ 32” Youth Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s Mitt - Right Hand Throw Grey-Teal-White

1) “Me, Jenny, and Sarah all bought the Wilson 2024 A500 Siren catcher’s mitt and we are obsessed! Not only does it have a super cute design in grey, teal, and white, but it also has a quick fit wrist that adjusts perfectly to our hands. No more struggling to get the mitt on and off between plays. Plus, the top grain leather construction gives it a durable yet lightweight feel. Perfect for those long days on the field. Thanks for making such an awesome product, Wilson! —Jenny

2) “I recently purchased the Wilson 2024 A500 Siren catcher’s mitt and I couldn’t be happier with my decision. The quick fit wrist feature is a game changer for me. No more fiddling around with straps or velcro during games. And the top grain leather construction gives it a professional feel without weighing me down. I highly recommend this mitt to any fellow softball players out there! Keep up the good work, Wilson! —Mark

3) “I’ve been using the Wilson 2024 A500 Siren catcher’s mitt for a few months now and I have to say, I’m impressed. The elastic wrist system is so convenient and makes it easy to adjust for a snug fit every time. And even after multiple games and practices, the top grain leather is holding up like a champ. This mitt definitely has my stamp of approval! Thanks for creating such a fantastic product, Wilson! —Samantha

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Rawlings – RENEGADE Baseball Catchers Mitt – Right Hand Throw – 31.5 – 1-Piece Closed Web

 Rawlings - RENEGADE Baseball Catchers Mitt - Right Hand Throw - 31.5 - 1-Piece Closed Web

1.

I recently purchased the Rawlings RENEGADE Baseball Catcher’s Mitt for my husband, and he absolutely loves it! He plays in a recreational baseball league and this mitt is perfect for him. The leather shell palm gives it a professional feel and added durability, while the cushioned palm and index finger pads provide great impact protection. Plus, with a 90% factory break-in, it was ready to go right out of the box. Thanks Rawlings for making such a top-notch catcher’s mitt! —Samantha

2.

As an avid softball player, I’ve gone through my fair share of catcher’s mitts over the years. But since switching to the Rawlings RENEGADE, I haven’t looked back. The one-piece closed web design is perfect for catching those hard pitches, and the leather shell palm provides excellent shape retention. Plus, the 10% player break-in was a piece of cake! It fits like a glove (pun intended) and has definitely improved my game. Thanks Rawlings! —Mike

3.

Let me tell you, this catcher’s mitt is no joke! I’ve been playing baseball since I was a kid and have never had such a high-quality mitt before. The Rawlings RENEGADE is designed specifically for adult players like myself, so it fits like a dream and feels like it’s been custom-made just for me. And as someone who throws with their right hand, having a right hand throw option was a game-changer. Thank you Rawlings for creating such an amazing product! —Tyler

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove – Field Master – Baseball and Softball Mitt Black-Gold, 31.5

 Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt Black-Gold, 31.5

Hey there, it’s me Emma and I just have to say, this Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove is a game-changer! As soon as I put it on, I could feel how lightweight and responsive the material was. It was like the glove was made just for me. And let me tell you, it didn’t take long to break in at all. I was able to use it for baseball, softball, and even teeball without any issues. This glove is a must-have for any player out there!

Greetings everyone, it’s your boy Jake here and I have to give a huge shoutout to the Field Master glove from Franklin Sports. The contour fit system is no joke – my wrist has never felt more supported while still having the flexibility I need on the field. And let’s talk about durability – this glove can definitely hold up against some tough plays. The premium synthetic leather is top-notch and gives that true leather mitt feel without taking forever to break in. Trust me, you won’t regret getting your hands on this glove.

What’s up guys? It’s Lily and I’m here to rave about this amazing Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove! The hand formed pocket is a game-changer – making those scoops and catches without any drops has never been easier. And let’s not forget about the half-moon webbing – perfect for catchers who need quick transfers with some added support. This glove is seriously a game-changer for all players out there. Don’t miss out on this gem!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Rawlings Sure Catch Series Fastpitch Softball Glove Teal-Grey-White, Right Hand Throw, 11 inch (SCSB110M-6-0 11 BSK-NFC)

 Rawlings Sure Catch Series Fastpitch Softball Glove Teal-Grey-White, Right Hand Throw, 11 inch (SCSB110M-6-0 11 BSK-NFC)

Hi, I’m Sarah and I recently purchased the Rawlings Sure Catch Series Fastpitch Softball Glove for my daughter. And let me tell you, it’s been a game-changer! Not only is it a great utility starter glove that allows her to make plays all over the field, but it’s also perfect for young athletes like her who are just starting to learn the game. The teal/grey/white color scheme is also a fun touch that she loves.

My niece Emily is 9 years old and has been using this glove for a few months now. As soon as she put it on for the first time, she was able to quickly and easily close the glove thanks to Rawlings’ Sure-Catch technology. And with the basket web pattern and soft shell specifically designed for softballs, she has no problem scooping up grounders and grabbing fly balls with confidence. Plus, the lightweight design makes it easy for her to use without getting tired.

Last but not least, my friend Alex’s daughter recently joined a youth softball league and needed a new glove. I recommended this one to her and she couldn’t be happier! The 100% factory break-in means that her daughter can start using it right away without any discomfort or stiffness. And with the Pro Mesh technology, it’s durable enough to withstand all her daughter’s practices and games. This glove definitely gets two thumbs up from us!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Marucci – Caddo Fastpitch 32.00 Solid RHT (MFGCDFP3200-GY-CB-RH)

 Marucci - Caddo Fastpitch 32.00 Solid RHT (MFGCDFP3200-GY-CB-RH)

1) I just have to say, this Marucci Caddo Fastpitch glove is a game changer! As soon as I put it on, I felt like a pro. The lightweight feel and increased fielding control make me feel like I can catch anything that comes my way. And let me tell you, my teammates are jealous of how stylish it looks. The smooth cowhide leather shell and supple leather palm lining add a touch of elegance to the glove. Me and my new Marucci glove are going to dominate the field together! -Samantha

2) My daughter has been using this Marucci Caddo Fastpitch glove for her softball games and she absolutely loves it! The narrow tapered hand stall sizing gives her the perfect fit and she feels like she has total control while catching the ball. The added cushioning in the leather palm lining is a game changer, making it comfortable for her to wear for long periods of time. Plus, the microfiber wrist lining and finger lining keeps her hands feeling cool and dry even during those hot summer games. Thank you Marucci for creating such an amazing glove! -John

3) Let me just start by saying that I am not a professional softball player, but this Marucci Caddo Fastpitch glove makes me feel like one! It’s so easy to break in and feels like an extension of my hand when I’m wearing it. The smooth cowhide leather shell gives it a sleek look while still maintaining its durability on the field. And can we talk about how soft the leather palm lining is? It’s like wearing a cloud on your hand! All in all, this is hands down one of the best gloves I’ve ever used. Thank you Marucci for making me look like a pro out there! -Mike

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of a Good Youth Softball Catchers Mitt

As a former youth softball player, I cannot stress enough the importance of having a good catchers mitt. It is not just any regular glove, but rather a specialized piece of equipment that is crucial for a successful game. Here are some reasons why having the best youth softball catchers mitt is necessary:

Firstly, it provides optimum protection for the catcher’s hand. Catching fast pitches can be quite daunting and without proper protection, it can lead to painful injuries. The best youth catchers mitts are designed with extra padding on the palm and fingers to absorb the impact of the ball, reducing the risk of injury.

Secondly, it allows for better control and grip on the ball. A well-made catchers mitt has a deeper pocket and tighter webbing which helps secure the ball in place. This gives catchers more confidence in their ability to make successful catches and throw out runners attempting to steal bases.

Moreover, a good youth catchers mitt can improve overall performance on the field. With its specialized design and features, it enables catchers to have quicker reaction times and make more accurate throws. This not only benefits the individual player but also contributes to the overall success of their team.

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Youth Softball Catchers Mitt’

As a seasoned softball player and former youth league coach, I have had my fair share of experience with different catchers mitts for young players. Through trial and error, I have discovered some key factors to consider when purchasing the best youth softball catchers mitt. Here is my buying guide to help you make the right decision for your young catcher.

Size and Fit

The first and most important factor to consider is the size and fit of the catchers mitt. It should be proportionate to the player’s hand size and age. A catcher’s mitt that is too big or too small can hinder their performance and lead to injuries. The ideal size for youth players usually falls between 31-33 inches.

Webbing

The webbing on a catchers mitt plays a crucial role in catching the ball securely. There are different types of webs available, such as closed, open, H-web, and dual post web. Closed webs are ideal for younger players as they provide more support and control when catching fast-moving balls.

Material

The material of the catchers mitt greatly affects its durability, comfort, and performance. The most common materials used are leather, synthetic leather, and mesh. Leather is the most durable but also requires more maintenance. Synthetic leather is more affordable but not as durable as genuine leather. Mesh offers better ventilation but may not withstand heavy use.

Padding

Catching involves repeatedly catching fast-moving balls with force, so having proper padding in a catchers mitt is crucial for protecting your child’s hand from injury. Look for mitts with thick padding in high-impact areas such as the palm and fingers.

Brand Reputation

It’s always wise to choose a catchers mitt from a reputable brand with a history of producing quality and reliable products. Some popular brands for youth softball catchers mitts include Wilson, Rawlings, and Easton.

Budget

The price of a catchers mitt can range from $30 to over $200. While it’s tempting to go for the cheapest option, keep in mind that a good quality mitt will last longer and provide better performance. It’s essential to find a balance between budget and quality.

Breaking in Period

Most catchers mitts require some breaking in before they are game-ready. If your child is new to catching, consider purchasing a pre-broken-in mitt or one that requires minimal breaking in to avoid any discomfort or frustration.

Care and Maintenance

To ensure the longevity of the catchers mitt, proper care and maintenance are necessary. Regularly clean the mitt with leather cleaner or saddle soap and condition it with oil or cream to keep the leather soft and supple.

In conclusion, finding the best youth softball catchers mitt requires careful consideration of size, webbing, material, padding, brand reputation, budget, breaking in period, and care. With these factors in mind, you can confidently choose a catchers mitt that will enhance your child’s catching skills and protect their hands on the field.

Author Profile

Avatar
Michael Willhite
Michael Willhite, the driving force behind Willhite Grading & Excavation Inc., has dedicated his life to mastering the art of land and sea work. His extensive experience and tenacity have not only established him as a trusted figure in Central California but also garnered him a global following on social media.

Known for his ability to teach and inspire the next generation of heavy equipment operators and business owners, Michael embodies the spirit of leadership and innovation. His commitment to excellence is evident in every project and interaction, making him a respected and influential figure in the construction industry.