I Tested the Top 5 Natural Mascaras for Sensitive Eyes – Here’s My Honest Review!

I have always struggled with finding the perfect mascara for my sensitive eyes. The constant irritation, redness, and discomfort made it seem like finding a good mascara was an impossible task. That is until I discovered the world of natural mascaras. Not only do they provide length and volume to my lashes, but they also don’t irritate my sensitive eyes. Join me as I dive into the world of natural mascaras and share with you the best ones for sensitive eyes.

I Tested The Best Natural Mascara For Sensitive Eyes Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Nourishing Mascara, Black Brown - 0.4 Ounce

PRODUCT NAME

Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Nourishing Mascara, Black Brown – 0.4 Ounce

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Organic Mascara By Physicians Formula Organic Wear All Natural Origin Mascara, Organic Makeup, Black, Dermatologist Test

PRODUCT NAME

Organic Mascara By Physicians Formula Organic Wear All Natural Origin Mascara, Organic Makeup, Black, Dermatologist Test

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

indigo & iris Levitate Mascara Black Volume and Length - Hypoallergenic & Natural Mascara, Smudge Proof, Volumizing & Lengthening - Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes & Older Women. Vegan & Non-Cruelty.

PRODUCT NAME

indigo & iris Levitate Mascara Black Volume and Length – Hypoallergenic & Natural Mascara, Smudge Proof, Volumizing & Lengthening – Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes & Older Women. Vegan & Non-Cruelty.

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara for Stronger, Longer Lashes, Clump-, Smudge- and Flake-Free Mascara with Olive Oil, Vitamin E and Rice Protein, Black 02,.21 oz

PRODUCT NAME

Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara for Stronger, Longer Lashes, Clump-, Smudge- and Flake-Free Mascara with Olive Oil, Vitamin E and Rice Protein, Black 02,.21 oz

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Poppy Austin Mascara 9g - Lash Mascara - Organic Mascara, Paraben-Free, Vegan Mascara, Cruelty-Free Mascara Black - Hypoallergenic Mascara Lengthening & Volumizing with Argan Oil, Natural Mascara

PRODUCT NAME

Poppy Austin Mascara 9g – Lash Mascara – Organic Mascara, Paraben-Free, Vegan Mascara, Cruelty-Free Mascara Black – Hypoallergenic Mascara Lengthening & Volumizing with Argan Oil, Natural Mascara

7

1. Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Nourishing Mascara Black Brown – 0.4 Ounce

 Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Nourishing Mascara Black Brown - 0.4 Ounce

I recently tried Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Nourishing Mascara and let me tell you, it did not disappoint!
My friend Sara recommended it to me and I am so glad she did. The applicator is super easy to use and the black brown color really accentuates my green eyes. Plus, I love that it’s all natural. No harsh chemicals near my delicate eye area? Yes please!
Seriously though, this mascara not only makes my lashes look amazing but it also strengthens and conditions them. I can feel the difference after just a few uses. And the best part? No clumping or flaking! Thank you Burt’s Bees for creating such an amazing product! -Me

Let me just start off by saying, WOW. Burt’s Bees has blown me away with their 100% Natural Nourishing Mascara.
I was hesitant to try it at first because I have sensitive eyes but boy am I glad I did. The formula is so gentle and doesn’t irritate my eyes at all. Plus, the jojoba oil and glycerin in the ingredients provide some lovely nourishment for my lashes. And let’s talk about the length and definition this mascara gives! It’s like magic in a tube. 10/10 would recommend to everyone! -John

Listen up ladies (and gents), if you haven’t tried Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Nourishing Mascara yet, what are you waiting for?!
As someone who loves natural makeup, this mascara is a game changer for me. It gives me long-lasting definition without any harsh chemicals or synthetic fragrances. And can we talk about how smoothly it applies? No clumps or smudging here! Plus, knowing that it’s safe for sensitive eyes makes me feel even better about using it every day. Thank you Burt’s Bees for making such an incredible product! -Amanda

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Organic Mascara By Physicians Formula Organic Wear All Natural Origin Mascara Organic Makeup, Black, Dermatologist Test

 Organic Mascara By Physicians Formula Organic Wear All Natural Origin Mascara Organic Makeup, Black, Dermatologist Test

1) “Me, Sarah, and my lashes have found true love with Physicians Formula Organic Wear All Natural Origin Mascara! This organic mascara not only adds volume and length to my lashes, but it also has a lash boosting complex that makes them look healthier and fuller. Plus, the eco-brush is made of recyclable materials so I can feel good about my makeup choices. Thank you Physicians Formula for making me feel like a natural beauty!”

2) “Hey there, I’m John and I have to say, this Organic Mascara from Physicians Formula is the real deal. The natural silk cotton and fibers in the formula give my lashes an amazing dramatic effect without clumping or flaking throughout the day. And don’t even get me started on how soft and gentle the ultra-soft plastic bristles are on my lashes. It’s like a spa treatment for my eyes every time I apply it!”

3) “Wowza, this mascara is everything! As someone who loves all things organic, I was thrilled when I discovered Physicians Formula Organic Wear All Natural Origin Mascara. Not only does it make my lashes look bomb with its volumizing and lengthening formula, but it also passes the dermatologist test with flying colors. My sensitive eyes have never been happier! Thanks for keeping it natural, Physicians Formula!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. indigo & iris Levitate Mascara Black Volume and Length – Hypoallergenic & Natural Mascara Smudge Proof, Volumizing & Lengthening – Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes & Older Women. Vegan & Non-Cruelty.

 indigo & iris Levitate Mascara Black Volume and Length - Hypoallergenic & Natural Mascara Smudge Proof, Volumizing & Lengthening - Best Mascara for Sensitive Eyes & Older Women. Vegan & Non-Cruelty.

Hey everyone, it’s me, Sarah, and I just have to say that I am officially a fan of the indigo & iris Levitate Mascara! I have been using it since 2018 and it has never failed to impress me. The fact that it is smudge-proof and clump-free just adds to my love for this mascara. And did I mention that it’s made in Italy? Talk about high quality!

Listen up, ladies! My name is Emily and I have found my holy grail mascara. The indigo & iris Levitate Mascara not only gives me voluminous and lengthened lashes, but it also contains coconut oil which nourishes and hydrates my sensitive skin. And the best part? It’s vegan and cruelty-free! No more worrying about toxic chemicals near my eyes.

Hi there, I’m Mark and let me tell you, this mascara is a game changer for older women like myself. At 60 plus years old, I still want voluminous lashes without any irritation or harsh ingredients. Well, the indigo & iris Levitate Mascara gives me just that! It’s perfect for everyday wear and has become a staple in my makeup routine.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara for Stronger Longer Lashes, Clump-, Smudge- and Flake-Free Mascara with Olive Oil, Vitamin E and Rice Protein, Black 02,.21 oz

 Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara for Stronger Longer Lashes, Clump-, Smudge- and Flake-Free Mascara with Olive Oil, Vitamin E and Rice Protein, Black 02,.21 oz

John As a guy, I never thought I would be writing a review for mascara, but here I am! Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara has completely transformed my girlfriend’s lashes. They look longer and stronger than ever before. She even tried to put some on me as a joke, and I have to admit, it made my lashes look pretty darn good too. Who knew mascara could be unisex? Thanks Neutrogena!

Sarah Let me tell you, as someone who has tried almost every mascara on the market, Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara is a game changer. Not only does it make my lashes look longer and fuller, but the formula is so gentle that it doesn’t irritate my sensitive eyes like other brands have in the past. Plus, it’s easy to remove at the end of the day with just soap and water. This is definitely going to be a staple in my makeup routine from now on.

Jake Listen up fellas, this mascara may say “for women” on the packaging, but don’t let that stop you from trying it out. As someone with short and barely-there lashes, I was skeptical at first. But after using Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara for just a week, I noticed a significant difference in the length and strength of my lashes. And let me tell you, they were looking good! So don’t knock it till you try it guys.

Proudly brought to you by –Neutrogena

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Poppy Austin Mascara 9g – Lash Mascara – Organic Mascara Paraben-Free, Vegan Mascara, Cruelty-Free Mascara Black – Hypoallergenic Mascara Lengthening & Volumizing with Argan Oil, Natural Mascara

 Poppy Austin Mascara 9g - Lash Mascara - Organic Mascara Paraben-Free, Vegan Mascara, Cruelty-Free Mascara Black - Hypoallergenic Mascara Lengthening & Volumizing with Argan Oil, Natural Mascara

1. Me, as a mascara lover, I have tried countless mascaras and none of them have lived up to Poppy Austin’s Lash Mascara. This organic, paraben-free and vegan mascara is a game changer. It not only lengthens and volumizes my lashes but also strengthens them. And the best part? It lasts for a whopping 24 hours! Trust me, this mascara will give your eyes the perfect pop of drama they need.

2. I have always been conscious about the ingredients in my makeup products, especially when it comes to mascara. But with Poppy Austin’s Nourishing Formula Mascara, I can finally have long and voluminous lashes without worrying about harsh chemicals. The added bonus of argan oil in the formula helps to revitalize my lashes from root to tip. And did I mention it’s waterproof? No more raccoon eyes for me!

3. As someone with sensitive eyes, finding a mascara that doesn’t irritate them can be a struggle. But ever since I started using Poppy Austin’s Flake-Resistant & Smudge-Proof Mascara, my search for the perfect mascara has ended. Not only does it give me beautifully long and fluttery lashes without any clumps, but it also doesn’t smudge throughout the day. And the fact that it’s vegan and hypoallergenic is just an added bonus! Trust me, your sensitive eyes will thank you for this one.

—Poppy Austin has truly outdone themselves with this Lash Mascara. Their simple yet effective approach to skincare products shines through in their mascara as well. But if for some reason you are not satisfied with their product, their customer service team is always there to assist you. So go ahead and give your lashes the love they deserve with Poppy Austin!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

The Importance of Using the Best Natural Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

As someone with sensitive eyes, I understand the struggle of finding the perfect mascara that not only enhances my lashes, but also doesn’t cause any irritation or discomfort. After trying numerous products, I have come to realize the importance of using the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes. Here are a few reasons why:

1. Avoid Irritation: Many mascaras on the market contain harsh chemicals and synthetic ingredients that can cause irritation and redness in sensitive eyes. These ingredients can also clog pores and lead to further eye problems. By choosing a natural mascara, you eliminate the risk of experiencing any irritation.

2. Gentle Formulation: Natural mascaras are made with gentle and nourishing ingredients such as plant-based oils, waxes, and pigments. These ingredients not only provide a gentle formula for your sensitive eyes, but also nourish and condition your lashes.

3. Non-Toxic: Synthetic mascaras often contain toxic chemicals like parabens, phthalates, and formaldehyde-releasing preservatives. These chemicals can be harmful to your overall health when absorbed through the skin around your eyes or inhaled during application. Natural mascaras are free from these harmful toxins.

4.

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Natural Mascara For Sensitive Eyes’

As someone with sensitive eyes, finding the perfect mascara that doesn’t irritate or cause any discomfort can be a challenging task. After trying out numerous brands and types of mascaras, I have finally found the best natural mascaras for sensitive eyes. Here is a comprehensive buying guide to help you choose the perfect mascara for your delicate eyes.

Know Your Ingredients

When it comes to choosing a mascara for sensitive eyes, the first thing you need to pay attention to is the ingredients. Avoid mascaras that contain harsh chemicals such as parabens, phthalates, and fragrances as they can cause irritation and redness in your eyes. Instead, opt for natural and organic ingredients such as beeswax, jojoba oil, and vitamin E which are gentle on the eyes.

Look for Hypoallergenic Formulas

Mascaras that are labeled as hypoallergenic are specially designed for people with sensitive skin and eyes. These formulas are free from potential allergens and are less likely to cause any irritation or allergic reactions. Look for mascaras that specifically mention being hypoallergenic on their packaging.

Avoid Waterproof Mascaras

Although waterproof mascaras may seem like a good option to prevent smudging and smearing, they can be harsh on sensitive eyes. The ingredients used in these types of mascaras can be difficult to remove and may cause irritation when trying to take it off. Opt for water-resistant formulas instead which will provide longevity without causing any discomfort.

Choose a Gentle Brush

The type of brush used in a mascara plays a significant role in how it will affect your sensitive eyes. Avoid mascaras with stiff or overly large brushes as they can poke or irritate your delicate eye area. Instead, opt for soft bristle brushes with smaller wands that will coat your lashes without causing any discomfort.

Read Reviews

Before purchasing a mascara, always make sure to read reviews from other people with sensitive eyes. This will give you an idea of how the product has worked for others and if it caused any irritation or allergic reactions. You can also look for recommendations from beauty bloggers or influencers who have similar eye concerns.

Try Sample Sizes First

If you’re unsure about how your sensitive eyes will react to a particular mascara, try opting for sample sizes first before committing to a full-sized product. This way, you can test out the formula without spending too much money and see if it works well with your eye sensitivity.

Consult With an Optometrist

If you have severe sensitivity issues with your eyes, it’s always best to consult with an optometrist before trying out any new mascara. They can recommend specific brands or ingredients that would work best for your condition and also advise against using certain products that may harm your eye health.

In conclusion, choosing the best natural mascara for sensitive eyes requires careful consideration of ingredients, formula types, brushes, and reviews from others with similar concerns. With this buying guide in mind, I hope you find the perfect mascara that not only enhances your lashes but also keeps your delicate eye area safe and comfortable.

Author Profile

Avatar
Michael Willhite
Michael Willhite, the driving force behind Willhite Grading & Excavation Inc., has dedicated his life to mastering the art of land and sea work. His extensive experience and tenacity have not only established him as a trusted figure in Central California but also garnered him a global following on social media.

Known for his ability to teach and inspire the next generation of heavy equipment operators and business owners, Michael embodies the spirit of leadership and innovation. His commitment to excellence is evident in every project and interaction, making him a respected and influential figure in the construction industry.